Barely Cooking Club. Real meals. Almost no cooking skills.

A SMALL FOOD HOBBY

Start a Food-Tasting Notebook: A Small Hobby for Curious Eaters

Published by Barely Cooking Club ·

Choose two versions of one food, put a small sample of each on a plate, and write down what you notice before deciding which you prefer. Two crackers or two apple varieties are enough to begin.

You do not need a tasting set, an expensive bottle or a vocabulary full of wine words. A food-tasting notebook can simply be a record of the textures, smells and flavors you enjoy—and the things you would buy again.

Start with a familiar food

Pick a category you already like and can safely eat. The point is to notice differences, not force yourself through something unpleasant.

Simple first comparisons
CompareA question to exploreSomething worth recording
Two apple varietiesWhich texture and balance of sweetness and tartness do I prefer?Variety, ripeness as you find it, and whether both were served cold
Two plain crackersWhich one would I choose alone, and which with my usual spread?Brand or type, salt level as you perceive it, and the spread used later
Two familiar chocolates suitable for youWhat do I notice about texture, sweetness and the flavor after swallowing?Product name, listed cocoa percentage if relevant, and serving conditions
Two prepared hummus flavorsWhich would I want in a wrap rather than just on a spoon?Flavor, ingredients, and the bread or vegetable used for a second comparison

Buy only what you can use afterward, or start with things already open in your kitchen. Two apple varieties may differ in more than variety alone; ripeness and storage can differ too. Your notes describe these particular samples, not a universal ranking of every apple with the same name.

Set up a small, unhurried tasting

You need the foods, a plate or two small bowls, clean utensils, drinking water and a notebook or notes app. Add a knife and board only if the food needs cutting.

  1. Prepare small portions. You can taste a little without opening enough food for a party. Keep the rest stored according to the label.
  2. Make the serving conditions similar. Use roughly equal pieces and avoid serving one sample fridge-cold while the other has been sitting out. Record differences you cannot control.
  3. Choose one question. “Which cracker do I prefer with hummus?” is easier to use than “Which food is best?”
  4. Give yourself a few quiet moments. Look, smell, taste if suitable, then write a short observation before discussing it with someone else.

The UC Davis introduction to sensory tasting describes appearance, aroma, taste, mouthfeel and texture as useful dimensions. It also explains why consumer tastings may use water, plain crackers, coded samples and quiet individual evaluation. This home activity borrows a few approachable ideas; it is not the university’s testing protocol.

Have water between samples. A suitable plain cracker can be useful if it does not conflict with your dietary needs or the comparison itself. You do not need to keep tasting when you are no longer enjoying it.

Separate what you notice from what you like

An observation describes the sample. A preference says what you want. They can fit in the same notebook without becoming the same thing.

These words are prompts, not expected results. If all you can write is “crunchier than the other one,” that is a useful note. You do not have to identify a hidden ingredient or agree with a description printed on the packet.

Copy this notebook template

Use a separate row for each sample. Leave a blank when you do not notice anything worth recording.

A blank tasting record to copy into your own notes
RecordSample ASample B
Date, food and product or variety________________________________
Serving conditions or preparation________________________________
Appearance and aroma________________________________
Texture, taste and aftertaste________________________________
Would I choose it? Why, and for what use?________________________________

Under the table, add one line: “Next time I want to compare…” That gives the hobby somewhere to go without requiring you to collect a cupboard full of products.

Keep price or value in a separate note. You might prefer one sample’s taste but choose another for everyday use. Neither decision needs an argument about which product is objectively better.

Try hiding the brands, if that sounds fun

If someone can set the samples out, ask them to label the plates A and B and keep a note of which is which. Write down your observations before revealing the products. This may make the activity feel different, but it does not remove every influence on a preference.

Never hide ingredient or allergen information. Check what everyone can safely eat before covering a brand name, keep the packaging available, and let anyone skip a sample. The FDA advises checking food labels each time, because ingredients can change.

With a friend, compare notes after each person has written something. “I liked the softer one” and “I liked the crisp one” can both be the whole answer. This does not have to be an ingredient-guessing contest.

Let the next comparison use what is left

Instead of buying two new things immediately, give the current food another job. Compare your crackers plain one day and with the same spread another day. Note that you have changed the serving context, rather than treating the second choice as a contradiction.

Or take the preference into dinner. If you found a hummus flavor you like, put it into a no-cook plate or wrap. If shopping for small amounts is the sticking point, our guide to handling extra packages shows how to think about what remains after a meal.

You can keep the notebook occasional. One pair of foods and a few honest words are enough for a session; there is no course to finish and no expert title you need to earn.

How this guide was prepared

Prepared with AI-assisted research and writing using the primary sources linked above. The combinations and notebook are suggestions; no kitchen testing or tasting session was performed for this guide. No personal results or expert review are claimed. Questions or corrections? Contact Heather Gowrie.